%PDF-1.4
%
1 0 obj
<>stream
application/pdf
10.1080/13504851.2018.1478386
en
Alternatives to polynomial trend-corrected differences-in-differences models
Vincent Vandenberghe
Routledge
Applied Economics Letters, 2019. doi:10.1080/13504851.2018.1478386
Treatment-effect analysis
differences-in-differences (DD) models
correction for trend differences
parallelism
Journal
Applied Economics Letters
© 2018 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
1350-4851
1466-4291
26
5
358
361
10.1080/13504851.2018.1478386
https://doi.org/10.1080/13504851.2018.1478386
VoR
2018-12-10T12:13:07+05:30
Arbortext Advanced Print Publisher 11.0.3433/W Unicode
2019-01-11T01:27:21-08:00
2019-01-11T01:27:21-08:00
Treatment-effect analysis; differences-in-differences (DD) models; correction for trend differences; parallelism
iText 4.2.0 by 1T3XT
uuid:b227eaff-780d-4c2c-9f95-fc1dd61abbb8
uuid:f9a7df55-e9c9-4f05-8891-ecb67fba091f
2018-05-24truewww.tandfonline.com10.1080/13504851.2018.1478386www.tandfonline.comtrue2018-05-2410.1080/13504851.2018.1478386
endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<>
endobj
4 0 obj
<>stream
xXK6ϯ(xvڦ=d[)gl,KGʟNV{mAC҉ty<z0bwXF{j'{c{qmx[T
V
37 ,z'2;݉2{m2?$5Ohp}kam&Ho{d `h
,&282
܆2T0h&6Y.
{kGUpL{f3!,|'jjoyyd-L-<ܓd n.TM<>`3M?zԽlָ͵sXZ([W-! C}%o@ҳ70,
D|]0K^t
Z!XgfF,wX; O͘5ta96/%i=ث~*b{1M#q$CȰZ|漋yR,{,öLI/Y+ kq\|c(3ZCIu:qm}K"D߳(^
~;i9ۗ&]wq(֠0#h_Q|ދbәzlE"!>͵)Qps˴~wcaE +q:Փk1~24\jup!H?|:9c#=.uGrv1/|:q%_&7&zI+9LڄJuSulR+בbY\SUN:;GB)M#1Lܶ7{YA6i>eƼ1I{=e Cpd[-urC0ajn+_8twcD.ZK졈wv+l{6/]bI
Nܴ.Uny_ĉ#]dkAE-w:W
RX|~h+Ѵ^'2I#GWౡ-ꝑ- n{
OK#HWx@aMN~*S.k6ؿiQ0z3B^#R.r:Hʣ`eMk.Po}
%A6%KCqˑ^쯨])X#S/2)!W^~n7W?p4JS֠orK<)![npmߐʓYQc ~5?֘WU*R.v=4P)|ߎ ge("Zqp}y&-NsН,tu]fT ?JJ\
endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<>stream
xgQ!`BDppK@3ĉ%8Cg*Z
[+x(+]L₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮^?[h~^>+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.₮+.zO-o}>^Oڅ*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*r*SWPWt5ktUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW9]tUNW+*jt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkNWCW5՚jjjt5tZsZ9]
]֜VkEwSޛ^k]za'w/BW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]qAW\t]q!ꟿ9 QC
endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<>stream
x}UuswEd|QA@e&R51tH&0k( ,A3,XbQT
!=s}{}w!B!B!B!B!B!Bͧ76E?>8:9;dGOUpGGAQ?*}v_"}vώ9V(.J(8{¿3@keWtݤ~]! W_K2K94>#M}@uE on|wN;[uQ% Omzw'n nKS}7/@N{LRwSs/@.{md,=(~ϫG~4`,a8فx8o.mxUԟuL߶/?o-y)?\w|`jwLd.?Xʟk=r;^Kϴ 6ωY .iYHoKʰ Q$NTN;!%_ sUMe9.X/,g;0XLzi`odܚ̤`˿dڳtw'rQ/H鏘($GO?ZzP.)~HOIXZU4:WzH8GQ-!Ve
R6?ɦz. !/Q53[HGY5_1_iC6tvǝ⹂x"HOG%1|t}= Ynfqal[/k95>)=aVݯQ#=]Vu`ht1[5ғoĿsǤG#߈!ңQoky鏉߈CKOFyo&6~#+=I|F?Kz2ovLߔoĿ1}`w}_`_~dc_~d5})~~+Jz߾=J*_l **?_C>- ?_>_Y ϰ 'p~S/ ev9hS. %O ?_.*4 S, O ?_&j . %O ??.$ , / gRw9/ 6@%?IʍL{>_Wl`㑕)~4vv8/\ #65XѨ˃,1i)zhBʓ}y 8ǃd_ƜW4hA?:O^fSn[6M2huo1/;/?]Ȭ?d~2~OLW,_1{9̚?f~ߙ,OSd$Y?MFO
SedY?]O~K?I~ڔ8N?~!H?Y~)J?~1}L?Y~ޔ<~t
~=
4R*VNyOv$:4zjyK?+ի>ʚiM?c3pjSL͡8s?[xSp<;Ϧ:x?J_L=/";?%;?_?J/¿!n~S<b:[b:vÿ
V~v}'[(=AP?hzS~t||Q-O?J!/G)ŴZ _: _G[ Bε ?(A]RxvGon~r<u1'/o^?JaYq-}?64~0xNj
N(d?
??++?WV??_Yպ_7,=w?`58Az0v9.b`49d}จ#rɸ争ғQu'o&=eN=_z2nbdszdu'Iש\7\z2
zÑңq7uO+\/Ϋ#=];Nz4Ns^\Z:Vs&$Fz4.p|\MѨ<ңeeӥiFI 1[dV̕ك1-=L\Ix>;{Qw-[?_]/v)OwK78Vjq|b)vO_{Y5,bICl.=`&as_(q_HO(@DqھUg%'R%=dj'=]K%o(\wo13T-V_#=p_-}G{JOf`9y Ըu9S'MT}?R?sPrٺ\1a
/2mirI4U-qRF+>4+zVܓ~K+k@Ʈ^ ^-Knee4WK+By-oZi-b>Lfō!C;XuWKѶO㫝ni5^u_$DTӬonKmmͨZ+|z5WaļJiAҗiv7/n+aV6S]eۧ>_GZ3M;W?x
ugaÕw{!B!B!B!B!B!Bx
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<>stream
x]nQb cJУ72xh,Uw5yS%Q myxx8p^e1X6s{;Kٕ?~dR?XJ>-/-cv&;}eq#q:5Ŀ
"!_v@@#8c77> m9}I#@@\ק@#LFx Ph 5?Д(DgwqfRv@l?&[@iOp<O}'
Z_-(ë5&z-?~U=w:ꌓ-'|罀]y~h*- BUyl+drT_?P.^OğUb'[o\G9Az'[3w-\J9O?C|O=4OoʟggΤl<7Δ=l~|)cGOOOSn4x=[Gh/?e#Ǐ{[g799ɞlV|ڳI^Uϟ?(l?S~%[{Tm=7?7O1sOSl+\Aig?og/6=??egyzz^"l(7#+:Z撽>PtEGVnW^l+4*Ӿw?TbWJL{L.JzL%&>=1^~
yg@%){MQ9(K?b'W?)^GJ;B٫hnoocG({A&p^_`BG;?=MQ#=MaGZ8ң^0a&px/yL?/'yX?^
h'{)*p 0Fr<&LJ?/jzYP59OeQSQs{?g(DM,?5l?;5_eC"jP{{.b[Eم)Cq(OF'PEg}_F[EiYpBjs?͊! Ӧ[C5]Mm?5QY_PDMc}C5]U[EiDUCZ5PtQX_xW[E5~*k?f_l?'KW![EI5uUC*Us?E[})_U(OMQV_bWu SMԤU-@5f5U-@T5c5U-RSZԀlm+*骯
mˢ*ѪJlk*eF]QSWhp_Yjb뷀锽j+?OO,p8\ 'Bofɤ'9Urs%o~xO3?s. |C7?D9Cgs?G#.?_y-?I{///#Fa(Ja4$0$GaL?8aFIGE7?A?@ؤ}31k%H#93I{"|A?p;.&W=z;} UCk/?2?Yr !UeL'!BF={I'Q|pd?JԇNR 7KEːo
\]R 7H.0{)FטMBWM:5Ia7%X~'-ߔE'-ߔcQ^??l\vIa&pO[5QGآ
:NQ%??l64oVk[~??l:oܯ_Ia/w ߅-O[/oآ;Rs)ߗeX?GtIaN-O[m]آ;Ub5߯%ׁ[@-Ⱦ??l~>5[.Eߎ'[PgFEa0o/hO[c]wOOON!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!?#Y3!Ǩp8dE
ũA&E:5fI///695mԄ3Qϟ٫]ЗS>{5r5Lٱ\he>Uj R+ 4(p]ә%:5ޫ@?>{KwώK {ys:b/f/iنŞ#7775Cb_#;MhD`ϮQ92"
jmѥ/^Ѐؑ]ӯ;
Tì+dq%+7X!Kal[VF ًYzWıPMJ:wwwwًWA3ׯ_ًgFX)<BέO23rRN;l T~>x||^"TUZyG+ͯE?
g'wrP+wSk-A.}ډrzUs _^^
i*nů_O?ԹX͈҇{>6UUeP;?j>ϠE%?
/|OA Osy4T pćB<{tcF2~n*8N]Isߓ}@WOh8g@ eK} }r2O CP:rL/// uhPvCNDYx<2/Kv97>,'v5h,aсͯ\Owu b1
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<>stream
xiŹ{d .*.zUp AE5MqI(`P"(0l,3ә3g`}~wUULuOj3La/lUiiRZŧozt{S7ۧ&=ec'>셒FRz~͊'G\ =⠑/nxSZ9N15A5t,X*=bWb|ZnySB~
/_xVEf+n=n4ڌ\~;8q7l5Kq?8餱CL\s4[1fI4N,3/ps'y"hxgN<5?ສ>;nrfnyV71,-%Ŏ&Rb9C{LCcL;IoPP聬]XkxZcS-`%ohZ?\XmPZ9k̏;[ KaL 2V)X
ǘ*` T[R\mr 1M|kn QXxLS0(ʉZjc*wEBsVVO3XlNb5
hq>a"`XRrP@k10(VS<.ͻmflփ11v*l4!ʘXi2PmW͝k:̆l4WaFW&VLLM+ߟ- ?
Vb>{¼wmu |^ޏ&U
|[ j%{ uL|*n3OW+VMvc<\+Eޱ$ZWodѼ:k#@o*WE^9A&sdVSf5HKq%}]uX>;Mf22XbU/`IfKtePI^lkihM(2~=Sϕ&bjg㸾l8MmC=;ߔ;`FmSaӯU_s
@ ^7NN(b]Xw8|H6\Tb 0uR巆Csz*|.XWT
pbƺT;'$$b|P.x<fϯF4soKv*A|ܒT/g$51x*S3c^V8pX's+)q>B@ YfV%jd5VZ^⡘pŪi!PC7Wg(W,cq3`bn'MzY>bV73>LGzpuQM7
4?NYoK3x#v5:SNR@=JܭX|g-*@%bz9n1TNcJNKH7;FMz ]oDTB/LX/38:ଌkƌ8{a
lր
AۦЋpb}Z:3
ր
DX*L?B&,OQљֆ第[2rsU1>9?ޠ|d[RpV7h|oLri>x
kO7j OiBv*j_C
M*镹XG>;gK1pR b E$K 7p ?3^Sȇao@hU
ΊeyOQ]'XΊ5[E2O37t ;B$v7_7v +`Q|lp^yK+j {ZEN7| B"֫Gio@ k_bo AjU
Ίj#YA=[EuJةڒXGlnoA&:ZcYܶȊB{c2J|ŚQtWDP}dO«bB+߿ޠkWn*|JN6c#4T8X]=x6 Bbjcc fkUTmԣLx+3b
z4r*GhbU;z8
\~tUu?
=B5suM6d6sB[1ɟq'wVD-,3hq&پDJmvC-BZb{:{n*
^*Zy>N~TZ^DM+ϻ<(joFPK+PW+}m`ݯ;S+{Noeƭ |kK-ZU1FWjIxeժr|ފP+Kh̙}kblYZ^ԓ3Zy'¿WVӪ
!VkX;,M
l uj0-S+smyQ'6f>;$KYjxeVϙʬXP+hju-uxK'X]WʘXkC#!6U^ER+#bebOCM"_W&J[)D"O7Hs^ƀWV:bm52i?ܪVb-}Ş^",Zn)!Z5W\=
52CRpŞ ^PirŞ ^$7Z1Zڕ|0}xe FDQt''WiK?<'|U
Ɗŀ:&ZY8%Z6$ZY4CS+LVĢ6tVŢ4VŢ6!k5YN+bQ[WDC+bQWDE+bQۄWEm^%LEm^)-Em^}{vc06 =x@2&9x'ZbMEm^qVfĢDW+#bQW